Ever feel like therapy options sound like alphabet soup? ACT, CBT… what do these acronyms even mean, and more importantly, how can they help you? When it comes to treating substance use disorders (SUD), these two heavyweights—Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)—stand out for good reason. Both offer powerful tools, but they take very different approaches. The trick? Finding the one that clicks with you or your loved one.
Let’s break it down: what are ACT and CBT, how are they different, and how do you choose the best fit for your recovery? Or, if you are just interested in getting help with substance use, you can just complete a form below and get scheduled for an immediate appointment.
Get Started Now
ACT vs CBT: What’s the Difference?
Think of ACT and CBT as two paths leading to the same goal: freedom from harmful thought patterns and behaviors. But the scenery and tools along the way are entirely different.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT):
CBT focuses on identifying and reshaping negative thought patterns. Think of it as mental rewiring—spotting the unhelpful narratives in your head and replacing them with constructive ones. It’s highly structured, often involving “homework” like journaling or practicing new coping skills. For addiction or substance use issues, CBT shines by helping you recognize triggers, manage cravings, and develop healthier habits.
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT):
ACT takes a softer, more philosophical approach. Instead of wrestling with your thoughts and feelings, ACT teaches you to sit with them. The goal? Psychological flexibility—accepting uncomfortable emotions while committing to actions that align with your values. It’s like learning to dance with your cravings rather than letting them lead.
While CBT feels like a science project (structured, step-by-step), ACT is more like art—fluid, intuitive, and values-driven. Both approaches have their strengths; it’s about which resonates more with your personal style.
How ACT and CBT Work in Addiction Recovery
CBT: Tools for the Here and Now
CBT arms you with actionable strategies for immediate challenges. Feeling the urge to relapse? CBT helps you break that urge into manageable pieces, identifying the thought spiral and stopping it before it gains momentum. It’s all about rewiring the brain to handle triggers more effectively.
ACT: Living a Values-Driven Life
ACT says, “Hey, cravings happen, but they don’t have to control you.” Instead of avoiding discomfort, ACT teaches you to accept it and focus on what matters most: your goals, relationships, and long-term aspirations. For someone in recovery, ACT builds resilience by reframing cravings as temporary distractions rather than insurmountable obstacles.
Examples of ACT vs CBT Interventions
ACT Intervention: Defusion Exercise
Imagine a person struggling with the thought, “I’ll never recover from addiction.” Instead of challenging the thought (as in CBT), ACT would encourage them to practice defusion. This involves noticing the thought without judgment and detaching from its power. The therapist might suggest saying the thought out loud in a funny voice or visualizing it as a passing cloud. The goal? To reduce the thought’s emotional grip and help the individual focus on values-driven actions, like attending a support group or reaching out for help.
CBT Intervention: Thought Record
In CBT, that same thought, “I’ll never recover from addiction,” would be dissected in a thought record. The therapist would guide the individual to identify evidence supporting and contradicting the thought. For instance, they might list past successes in staying sober, even for short periods, as evidence that recovery is possible. The process helps restructure the thought into something more balanced, like, “Recovery is hard, but I’ve made progress before, and I can again.”
Both interventions are powerful but serve different purposes. ACT focuses on accepting and moving through the thought, while CBT works to reshape it into something more constructive.
How to Choose Between ACT and CBT
Picking the right approach can feel like a high-stakes game, but here’s a cheat sheet:
- Comfort with Emotions: If you’re comfortable with the idea of exploring and accepting difficult emotions rather than changing them, ACT may be a better fit. ACT teaches individuals to live with discomfort without letting it control their actions, making it a strong option for those who seek inner peace with their cravings and urges.
- Need for Structure: CBT is highly structured and may involve homework and exercises, such as keeping a thought journal or practicing coping skills outside of therapy sessions. This structure can be beneficial for people who prefer a clear framework and tangible exercises. In contrast, ACT is more flexible and may appeal to those who want to build acceptance skills rather than strictly “fix” their thoughts.
- Focus on Long-Term Goals vs. Immediate Coping Skills: Both therapies can address short-term and long-term goals, but they approach them differently. CBT offers specific tools for managing immediate cravings and triggers, while ACT emphasizes commitment to long-term values, making it useful for maintaining sobriety beyond immediate recovery goals.
Professional Guidance Makes a Difference
Choosing between ACT and CBT (or using both!) is easier with a skilled therapist by your side. Here’s how they help:
- Personalized Assessment: A licensed therapist can assess your specific needs, triggers, and recovery goals to recommend the therapy that might suit you best. For example, if you struggle with intense cravings that seem difficult to manage, CBT’s skills-based approach could provide practical strategies. On the other hand, if you’re looking to create a value-driven life, ACT may offer a pathway to this goal.
- Hybrid Strategies: Many therapists are skilled in both ACT and CBT and may integrate techniques from each to create a hybrid treatment plan. This flexibility allows for a more personalized approach that meets your evolving needs in recovery.
- Ongoing Support and Adjustment: Recovery is an ongoing journey, and your needs may change over time. With professional support, you can adjust your therapeutic approach as you make progress, transitioning from one therapy to another if it becomes beneficial.
Working with a therapist can make it easier to understand and choose between ACT and CBT, providing you with guidance and support tailored to your unique recovery journey.
Common Questions About ACT and CBT for Substance Use Recovery
Can I Use Both ACT and CBT in Recovery?
Yes, many individuals benefit from a combination of ACT and CBT. Some people find it helpful to start with CBT to gain control over harmful thought patterns and then transition to ACT as they become more comfortable accepting difficult emotions. Combining both approaches can provide a comprehensive set of tools for managing both immediate triggers and long-term goals.
Which Therapy Is More Effective for SUD?
Both ACT and CBT have been shown to be effective for treating SUD, but their success often depends on the individual’s unique needs and preferences. CBT is well-established and has a large body of evidence supporting its efficacy in addiction treatment, especially for managing cravings and triggers. ACT, however, has gained popularity in recent years for its focus on values-based living and psychological flexibility, which can be particularly useful for long-term recovery.
Conclusion
Choosing the right therapy is a personal journey that can significantly impact your recovery from substance use disorder. Whether you feel drawn to the structured, skills-focused approach of CBT or the acceptance-based, values-oriented framework of ACT, finding the therapy that resonates with you is key. Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all solution in recovery. Contact us today to speak with a licensed therapist who can guide you in exploring ACT, CBT, or a combination of both to support your path to lasting recovery.
Substance Use Treatment in North Carolina
If you’re looking for some help with your substance use and live in North Carolina or wish to relocate for addiction treatment in Raleigh, NC, reach out to us by completing a form and we can help guide you through our offerings and see if you may be a fit for our PHP, IOP, or outpatient addiction therapy.
We are able to offer immediate appointments that can help you get started on your addiction recovery journey.
